Puzzle game maker: the rule is the game, and the rule gets written
Puzzle design is mostly testing: you have a rule, you build a room around it, and you find out whether anyone can solve it. Flockbay makes the rule cheap to change so you can spend your time judging the rooms. Free AI to start: Flockbay's AI and your own Claude, ChatGPT, agent or API key are free for your first build; after that, a plan keeps you building. It runs on Windows, macOS and Linux, on the official Godot engine.
The main page on this subject is What is an AI game maker that writes a real Godot project?.
AppImage, x86_64. Ubuntu 22.04, Debian 12, Fedora 39 or newer.
Intel or AMD Chromebook, with Linux turned on.
One rule, then everything that follows from it
Good puzzle games usually rest on a single mechanic that turns out to be deeper than it looks. Boxes that can only be pushed. A light that reveals one thing and hides another. Time that runs backwards in one room. The design work is finding out what the rule can do.
That means the rule has to be cheap to change. If altering how the mechanic behaves takes an afternoon of code, you will test three variants. If it takes minutes, you will test thirty, and the thirtieth is usually the good one.
Flockbay writes the rule as GDScript in your project. You describe the mechanic, it runs the result itself to check it works, you play it, you say what should be different, and it rewrites. That cycle is the entire reason this is useful for puzzles.
A level is an arrangement, and the arrangement is your call
A puzzle level is a specific arrangement that makes exactly one insight necessary, and every element in it is there on purpose. Procedurally generated levels tend to be solvable and boring, which is why the puzzle games people remember were laid out one room at a time.
So the rooms get built deliberately. Flockbay lays out the first ones from the brief you approved — the geometry, the boxes, the doors, the pressure plates — as nodes in the scene tree, and runs them to check they load and play. Whether the insight lands, or whether there is a stupid shortcut nobody saw, is something only playing tells you, and playing is your job.
When the fix is one block one cell to the left, describing it is slower than doing it. Godot's own editor is there in the Standard and Full views, so the 2D view moves the block, the TileMap panel fills the cell, and Godot's undo takes it back if the shortcut turns out to be the better puzzle.
The other half of level design is order. Which puzzle teaches the thing the next one requires. That ordering is judgement and it is yours.
More on this: Godot 2D game templates: what they hand you, and what they leave
Testing on yourself, then on someone else
You will get worse at judging your own puzzles the more you build them, because you already know the answer. That is a known hazard of the genre and no tool fixes it.
What helps is that Export makes a real native build for Windows, macOS or Linux, so handing it to a friend is a normal thing to do. Watching somebody get stuck in a place you thought was obvious is worth more than any amount of solo tuning.
When they get stuck in the wrong place, you come back and change the rule or the room. Usually the room.
A grid is something you paint, not something you give up on
The first question a puzzle designer answers is what shape the space is: 2D or 3D. That is not a cosmetic setting. It decides how Flockbay builds the scenes, and which of Godot’s views you work in, for the rest of the project.
In 3D you get real space. Sightlines, elevation, what you can see from where, what a room looks like from the other side, and terrain, water and weather from Godot plugins underneath all of it. A game about a building you have to understand is very much what that half is for.
In 2D you get a grid, which is what a great many puzzle games wanted in the first place. Ground is a map of covered cells, and which picture lands in each cell, where the edges fall and what the player collides with are all derived from it. So a room is walkable the moment it is painted, by Flockbay or by you. Whether a material stops a walker is declared rather than assumed, which means a wall and a floor are the same gesture with a different property — most of what a grid puzzle needs, geometrically. Declare no gravity and the character steers on both axes; declare gravity and the same body gives you a puzzle platformer instead.
Where this stops short is worth hearing now rather than in week three. Ground is tiles and only tiles: there is no pencil that draws an arbitrary curve of it. And nothing here makes animation. Flockbay can produce a single flat still image on request, but not a multi-frame sprite, so if a matched pair has to squash and pop when it clears, those frames come from you or from the Catalogue.
More on this: Looking for RPG Maker? This is a different kind of tool
It is a download, and the puzzles run on your machine
A desktop app for Windows, macOS and Linux, free to download, with Godot bundled inside. Games run locally on your machine. Building needs an internet connection because the chat and asset generation come over the network; playing does not.
The editor is free. Free AI to start: Flockbay's AI and your own Claude, ChatGPT, agent or API key are free for your first build; after that, a plan keeps you building.
More on this: AI puzzle generator: generating puzzles is easy. Generating good ones is not
Cutting is most of the job
You will build puzzles that work, are fair, and are boring. Those are the hardest to remove because nothing is wrong with them, and removing them is usually what turns a set of puzzles into a game.
A useful test is whether the puzzle taught anything or asked for anything new. If it did neither, it is padding, however clever the arrangement is.
The other common cut is the tutorial. Most puzzle games explain too much, because the designer is nervous. Watching one person play without a word from you will tell you exactly how much of your explanation was necessary, and it is usually less than half.
A starting project for this is the puzzle game templates.
Questions
- Can I make a grid or tile puzzle game?
- Yes, in the same app with the same chat. In a 2D project ground is a tile layer, painted by Flockbay and by you in Godot's TileMap panel; the tiles, the edges and the collision are derived from the coverage, and whether a material stops a walker is a property you declare rather than a game type you choose. What you will not get is animation — a single flat still image can be generated, a multi-frame sprite cannot.
- Are levels generated for me?
- Not procedurally. Flockbay lays out the rooms the brief describes and runs them to check they play. Whether a room teaches what it should is your call, made by playing it, and when the fix is one block, Godot's own editor moves it.
- Do I need to code the mechanic?
- No. Flockbay writes the GDScript. You describe the rule, play it, and say what needs changing.
- How do I share a build for playtesting?
- Export in the app makes a native build for Windows, macOS or Linux you can hand to someone, or a Web build for itch.io. It is also a standard Godot 4 project, so Godot's own export can take it to Android or iOS.
- What does it cost?
- The download is free. Free AI to start: Flockbay's AI and your own Claude, ChatGPT, agent or API key are free for your first build; after that, a plan keeps you building.
Free to download for Windows, macOS and Linux.
Download Flockbay free