Looking for RPG Maker? This is a different kind of tool

RPG Maker is a real product line, it is very good at one thing, and that thing is the tile-based 2D Japanese-style role-playing game. Grid maps, a database of items and skills, an event editor, a default battle system that works on day one. If that is the game in your head, RPG Maker will get you there faster than anything else, and you should use it.

It also has thirty years of tutorials, an enormous library of tilesets and sprites, and a community that has already solved whatever you are about to get stuck on. None of that is something a new tool can claim.

Flockbay is a different shape. It is worth two minutes to know which shape you want before downloading either one.

More on this: A Construct 3 alternative that does not ask you to give up 2D

Flockbay is a desktop app for Windows, and the first thing it asks when you create a project is which kind of game you are making, 2D or 3D. Two pictures, no default, and nothing is created until you pick one. It is the same app, the same builder and the same chat on either side, so the dimension is a setting the project carries rather than a different product.

So it is tile-based when you ask it to be. Pick 2D and what opens is already playable — a sky colour, a band of scenery along the horizon, ground with a ledge and a floating platform, and a person who walks, falls and jumps under the keys you press. Ground after that is a tile layer you paint: drag to lay it, drag to erase it, and the tiles, the edges and the collision all follow from which cells are ground instead of being picked one at a time. That is a pure function of the coverage, so painting the same cells in a different order draws the same map and a rebuild never reshuffles an edge you liked.

Two things fall out of that rather than being modes. Whether ground stops a walker is declared per material, so a path and a wall are painted the same way and only one of them stops anybody. And side-on or top-down comes from gravity: declare it and down is a direction, so steering is horizontal and a jump is available; declare none and the body steers on both axes with nothing to jump away from.

Pick 3D instead and you get the other set of tools — terrain shaped from elevation, water, weather, a day-night cycle, characters moving around a place rather than across a grid. What neither side ships is the genre. There is no default battle system waiting to be reskinned and no item database.

The engine underneath is Godot, which is open source. Your project is a Godot project. That is the answer to the lock-in question that eventually occurs to everyone who has spent a year inside a closed editor.

Instead of an event editor, there is Flockbay, which writes GDScript. You describe the behaviour and it writes the code inside your project. You do not open a script; you play the result and say whether it is right.

More on this: AI JRPG maker: the systems are the easy half

You give up the head start. RPG Maker hands you a working battle system, a working menu, a working save file and a map editor tuned for exactly one genre. Flockbay hands you an engine and a way to build on it, which is more freedom and more empty space.

You give up the asset ecosystem. Decades of RPG Maker tilesets exist because the format has been stable for decades, and they match each other because the same artists drew the wall and the floor. The Catalogue here is large and mostly sprites — 55,073 of its 60,648 objects, searchable by name with a picture of each — but it is a library rather than a matched kit for one genre.

You give up animation help. Flockbay builds from a library of ready-made objects, or with Godot's own shapes; it will not generate a walk cycle. If your game leans on a lot of original animation, those frames come from the Catalogue or from your own hand. That is the clearest gap in a flat project today and it is worth knowing before you plan around it.

You also give up the offline case. Building in Flockbay needs an internet connection, because the chat, asset generation and world data all come over the network. Playing what you built does not, but building does.

More on this: Puzzle games need a prototype in an hour, not a fortnight

A game that is not obviously made in a particular tool. The most recognisable thing about a stock RPG Maker game is that it is a stock RPG Maker game. When the ground is yours, the sprites are yours and the systems are written for your specific design, the result does not have a house style to escape.

Performance that belongs to your machine. The game runs locally on the copy of Godot bundled with the app, at your framerate, with your memory. Nothing streams and nothing renders in a tab.

And a genre boundary you can cross. If the RPG turns out to want a driving section, or a base you defend, that is a conversation with Flockbay rather than a fight with a tool that only knows one genre. The one boundary you settle up front is 2D or 3D, and you settle it on the screen that creates the project.

More on this: A Defold alternative when you would rather not write Lua

A role-playing game needs a save system, a pause menu, an options screen, a way to remap a key, and a title screen. RPG Maker hands you all of that on the first day and you never think about it again. That is a genuine convenience and it is worth naming.

Here each of those is a request. Save the game at campfires. Let the player rebind movement. Add a settings screen with volume and mouse sensitivity. Flockbay writes them as GDScript in your project and you check them by using them.

The difference in practice is a couple of evenings, not a couple of weeks, and the result matches your game rather than the default. Whether that is worth the evenings depends entirely on how much your game looks like the default.

Pick RPG Maker if you want the genre it is built for — grid maps, a party of four, a turn-based battle screen — and you want to be building maps within the hour. That is a good, specific want and it is extremely well served.

Pick Flockbay if the reason you have not started is that you wanted your own Claude or ChatGPT plan to write the code, and you would rather the tool did not decide the genre for you. Flockbay is free on your own AI: your Claude or ChatGPT plan, your own agent, or an API key.