Skip to content

No generator produces a platformer worth playing, and here is why

By Eduardo Orellana · Updated

A generator can write the movement code, fill a level with platforms and produce art in minutes. What it cannot do is decide whether the third jump is fair. Flockbay does the first part and checks it by playing; the third jump is yours to judge. Free AI to start: Flockbay's AI and your own Claude, ChatGPT, agent or API key are free for your first build; after that, a plan keeps you building. It runs on Windows, macOS and Linux, on the official Godot engine.

The main page on this subject is A platformer maker with no ceiling on it.

AppImage, x86_64. Ubuntu 22.04, Debian 12, Fedora 39 or newer.

Intel or AMD Chromebook, with Linux turned on.

Download for macOSDownload for WindowsDownload for Linux

What generation is genuinely good at

Code. A character controller with gravity, acceleration, air control, coyote time and input buffering is a well-understood piece of software that has been written ten thousand times. Having it produced in seconds instead of a fortnight is real value, and it is the largest single barrier for someone who does not program.

Content volume, up to a point. Filling a scene with props, laying out a rough grid of platforms, producing placeholder art so the level reads. This is scaffolding, and getting scaffolding for free is worth a lot.

Systems. Score, lives, checkpoints, menus, saving, a level select. Necessary, unexciting, and entirely writable.

What it is bad at, and will stay bad at

Difficulty. A generated level does not know that the player just learned the wall jump twenty seconds ago and needs one easy application of it before a hard one. It has no model of what the person holding the controller currently understands.

Rhythm. Good platforming sections have a cadence, a build and a release. Generated ones have uniform density, which is the same problem as a song with no dynamics.

Fairness. The difference between a jump that is tight and a jump that is unfair is a handful of pixels and cannot be seen from a description. It can only be found by playing it and failing at it, and then deciding whether the failure felt like your fault.

This is not a shortfall to be engineered away with a better model. Those judgements need someone who wants a particular experience to exist.

More on this: Rhythm games are an audio timing problem wearing a game costume

So the building is automated and the judging is not

Flockbay builds the levels and writes the GDScript inside your Godot project, from a brief you approved. Then it runs the game, sends input events, reads the debugger and captures the viewport, so a gap it made impossible or a script that will not parse gets caught before you ever see it.

What it cannot catch is whether the third jump is fair. So you play it, say the gap is too wide or the wall jump arrives too early, and it changes. When the fix is a matter of a few pixels, Godot's own 2D editor is right there: move the platform yourself, play it again, and Godot's undo takes it back if you were wrong. The code is the half that is the same in every platformer. Your judgment is the half that makes yours different from the other ten thousand.

And you are the judge throughout. Not writing the code has never meant not knowing when a jump feels wrong.

The tool itself

Flockbay is a desktop app for Windows, macOS and Linux with Godot bundled inside it. It downloads and installs. Your game runs locally when you press play, at your own framerate, which matters for a genre judged on input timing.

Building needs an internet connection, because generation and Flockbay come over the network. Playing what you built does not.

The download is free. Free AI to start: Flockbay's AI and your own Claude, ChatGPT, agent or API key are free for your first build; after that, a plan keeps you building. Flockbay builds from a library of ready-made objects, or with Godot's own shapes.

More on this: AI level generator: generate the ground, place the meaning

Where generated levels genuinely belong

There is one place procedural platformer levels work well, and it is worth naming: games where the level is meant to be disposable. Endless runners, roguelikes with short randomised rooms, daily challenge modes. There the player never expects an authored experience, and variety is the point.

Even then the pieces are usually authored. The good ones stitch together hand-made chunks with rules about which chunk can follow which, which gives you variety without the incoherence of pure generation.

That approach is entirely buildable here. Flockbay builds the chunks as scenes and writes the code that stitches them together at runtime, following the rules you describe. You play the runs and judge which chunks earn their place, and reshape one in the editor when it needs a human eye. It is a good example of the loop this tool is built around.

More on this: Make an endless runner where the tuning is the game

Judge the output by playing, not by looking

A generated level looks plausible in a screenshot almost always. Platforms are spaced, there are no impossible gaps, the shape has variety. It is only when you play it that the flatness shows: nothing builds, nothing surprises, every section asks the same thing.

So do not evaluate generated content visually. Play it as though someone else had made it, and notice whether you were ever nervous, relieved or pleased. If the answer is no for three minutes straight, the level is not doing its job however tidy it looks.

That is also the fastest way to work out which parts of the generation are worth keeping. Usually the answer is the scaffolding and the systems, not the arrangement.

More on this: Roguelike game maker: the run is a system, and systems are code

A starting project for this is the platformer game templates. The design note that goes with it is how Mario levels teach one mechanic at a time.

Questions

Will it generate a complete playable platformer?
It builds the levels and writes the code from a brief you approve, and plays them to check they run. Whether they are worth playing is your call: you play, say what is wrong, and it changes.
Can it generate levels at all?
It can lay out and fill space quickly. Treat the output as a first pass you play and correct, by telling Flockbay or by moving platforms in the editor yourself.
Do I need to code?
No. Flockbay writes the GDScript in your project and revises it when you say what is wrong.
Where does my project live?
On your disk, as a normal Godot project. Godot is open source.
What does it cost?
The download is free. Free AI to start: Flockbay's AI and your own Claude, ChatGPT, agent or API key are free for your first build; after that, a plan keeps you building.

Free for Windows, macOS and Linux. Flockbay builds the levels and the controller; you decide which jumps are fair.

Download Flockbay free