More indie games

The Undergrowth makes your body the progression system

4 min read

Most survival games make you stronger by handing you better tools. The Undergrowth makes you stronger by making you older, in a shared ecosystem where everything else alive is trying to do the same thing.

Growing up is the progression

The Undergrowth is an online multiplayer survival game where you hatch as a small, weak creature into an ecosystem that was already running before you arrived. You hunt, scavenge, drink, hide and grow. There is no gear tree and no character sheet — the thing that gets stronger is the animal, and the only way it gets stronger is by staying alive long enough to mature.

The verbs are the familiar survival ones: manage hunger, thirst, stamina, temperature, injuries and exhaustion, find water that is safe to drink, hold a shelter, avoid becoming somebody else’s meal. What makes this version unusual is that all of it is attached to a body that changes shape underneath you. A juvenile survives by stealth because it has nothing else to survive with. An adolescent starts contesting territory and food. An adult wins through strength, speed or intelligence — and by then the same patch of forest is a different game with the same controls.

That runs the difficulty curve backwards from the genre norm. Usually the world escalates while you tool up to meet it. Here the world stays exactly as dangerous as it was on your first minute and you are the only variable, which turns reaching adulthood into the achievement itself rather than a milestone on the way to one.

The other half is that the ecosystem is shared. Dense forest, underground tunnels, wetlands, cliffsides, rivers and hidden nests are stocked with AI wildlife and with other players running the exact same growth curve, so the apex creature stalking your water source is someone who earned it the way you are currently failing to. Weather and time of day move everybody around: heavy rain can open tunnels that were not passable yesterday, and a drought squeezes predators and prey onto the same shrinking pool.

Why the ecosystem is the design

The Rise of the Systemic Game is the essay this thing is standing on. It argues that the power of a systemic game comes from objects, characters, environments and rules that can act on each other, producing plans and accidents no designer wrote down. A drought that shrinks a river until a predator and its prey have to share it is exactly that — nobody scripted the ambush, the weather and the thirst meter did it between them.

How Games Use Feedback Loops is where the risk lives. Growing makes you better at hunting, hunting feeds you, feeding makes you grow: that is a positive feedback loop with no brake in it, and left alone it means the players who got a head start eat the ones who did not, forever. Survival games answer this with decay, migration, hunger that scales with size, or predators that notice a fat target. Which answer The Undergrowth picks will decide whether a fresh hatchling has any reason to log in on day forty.

Redesigning Death is the other lever, and the developers are explicit that death carries consequences. That is the sentence holding the rest up. If dying costs you the hours of growth you just banked, then every encounter is a real decision, and the stealthy ambush predator, the territorial brute and the fast-moving scavenger stop being cosmetic playstyles and start being genuine bets about how you intend to reach adulthood.

What you actually get

The Undergrowth is developed and published by Opendix[Studios], listed under Action, Adventure, Indie, Massively Multiplayer, Simulation and Strategy, and tagged for Early Access. It is coming to Windows, and the store page gives no date beyond coming soon. It is multiplayer all the way down — the categories are multiplayer, MMO, PvP and online PvP, and single-player is not among them.

Scope is the honest question. A persistent shared world with weather, life stages, AI wildlife and open PvP is a great deal of simulation for a small team to keep standing, and Early Access is the right shape for finding out which parts of it survive contact with actual players. What is in its favour is that the pitch is legible: you know what you would be doing in the first ten minutes, and you know what you would be doing in the tenth hour, and they are recognisably the same game.

If the appeal is being something small in a world built at the wrong scale, Project Ants is the closest neighbour on this list — an insect earning the map with new legs, which is the same trade The Undergrowth is making when it puts your abilities inside your body instead of inside an inventory.