More indie games

Bar After Bar makes your friends the difficulty setting

4 min read

Most driving games put the difficulty in the road. Bar After Bar puts it in the passenger seat — five friends, one mountain, and a car that gets harder to steer every time somebody lands a drink on the person holding the wheel.

Mix it, throw it, then try to steer

Five friends get in a car and drive to the top of a mountain. That is the premise, and it would be over in two minutes if the rest of the car were empty. It is not. The other verbs are mixing drinks and throwing them at each other, the whole way up, and the drunker you get the harder the driving becomes. The store page asks the only question the design actually cares about: how far can you make it?

The unusual part is where the difficulty lives. A driving game normally escalates through the road — tighter corners, worse weather, a timer, traffic coming the other way. Here the road is the constant and the driver is the variable. Nothing on the mountain gets harder. Your hands do. The obstacle is manufactured in the back seat, by people you invited.

That makes the drink an oddly precise object. It is not damage and it is not a pickup, it is impairment with a sender. Somebody mixed it, somebody aimed it, and what it costs the group depends entirely on who was holding the wheel when it landed. A hit on a passenger is a laugh. The same hit on the driver is the run.

Everyone being in the same car is the part that stops this collapsing into pure sabotage. There is no lead to protect and no finish line to get to first — there is one vehicle carrying the whole party, so every drink you throw is spent on the thing you are also riding in. It runs as online co-op for the group, with full controller support and a keyboard-only option, and it will let you drive the mountain single-player if you ever want to see the road sober.

A spiral with somebody at the other end of it

How games use feedback loops is the essay sitting underneath this. Its argument is that a positive loop snowballs — a lead compounds into a bigger lead, a slip into a worse slip — until something in the design corrects it. Bar After Bar is a positive loop aimed squarely at failure. Bad driving makes chaos in the cabin, chaos means more drinks land, more drinks make the driving worse, and the only thing that corrects the spiral is the run ending. For a party game that is a real answer rather than a missing one: the crash is the punchline, not the punishment, which is why the game measures how far you got instead of whether you won.

How Overcooked’s kitchens force you to communicate covers the co-op half. Its point is that most co-op games manufacture teamwork by handing players different powers or different information, while Overcooked gives everybody the same tools and lets the room generate the friction. A car is a much smaller room than a kitchen, and one of the people holding the same tools as everyone else is the only one who cannot put them down. That asymmetry is positional rather than mechanical, which is the sturdier kind — it belongs to the seat rather than to a class of player.

The secret of Mario’s jump and other versatile verbs is the argument for building this much out of one action. A single verb can carry a game as long as the context keeps changing what it means. Throwing a drink is a prank, a weapon, a bribe and a group suicide pact depending on who catches it, which corner you are on, and how much of the mountain the party has already banked. One verb, four meanings, no extra systems required, and what it is worth rises with every metre of mountain already behind you without anything in the game having to say so.

What you actually get

Bar After Bar is made and published by OneMan Tim, out now on Windows, and listed under Action, Casual and Indie. It plays single-player or in online co-op, supports controllers fully, offers a keyboard-only option and custom volume controls, and carries the accessibility tags for playing at your own pace and without timed input — a slightly funny set of labels on a game about losing motor control.

The store page is almost entirely video. One paragraph of text, then a wall of clips. For this kind of game that is the honest choice, because nobody has ever been sold a party game by a feature list. What you are buying is thirty seconds of your friends ruining something, and the page shows you precisely that instead of describing it.

If the appeal is a vehicle where the driving turns out to be the easy part, Cartel Pilots Wanted is the other one on this list — you and your friends fly cargo for a cartel, and the plane is the smallest problem in the plane. Same shape from the air: the machine is fine, the crew is the hazard.